A Discussion of COLA Alternatives - ThinkAdvisor
Social Security reform is again moving to the forefront of the political scene, and it’s one of the hot buttons in the current election rhetoric. Most recently, the announcement earlier this month of a 1.3% cost-of-living adjustment (COLA) for beneficiaries gave the issue another nudge, with news accounts of just how the current process for calculating COLA continues to fail in the quest to keep benefits from falling behind against inflation in the categories most important to seniors. In this regard, ThinkAdvisor contributor Ginger Szala offers an article discussing the importance of annual adjustments and highlighting several alternative measurement processes that could make the adjustment more tuned to the needs of seniors. Read her article here…
As presented in Ms. Szala’s article, the CPI-E (E for elderly) option would tend to generate a COLA slightly higher than the current CPI-W formula, while C-CPI-U (the “chained CPI”) option discussed off-and-on for several years would likely result in a lower COLA. Accordingly, the article indicates that current discussions focus more on the CPI-E as a change to the calculation process. All that aside, of course, no real action is anticipated until the overall Social Security reform issue gets attention in the 117th Congress, and there will be several proposals vying for consideration. In fact, one of the proposals on the table is the Association of Mature American Citizen’s (AMAC) Social Security Guarantee, a proposed legislative framework that includes a specific recommendation to alter the COLA process.
AMAC’s proposal calls for the implementation of a tiered approach to the calculation of Cost-of-Living Adjustments (COLA) as follows:
- For beneficiaries with a household income (Modified Adjusted Gross Income) level less than 150 percent of the federal poverty threshold (fpt), set an annual COLA range of 3 percent minimum – 4 percent maximum.
(Note: For purpose of illustration, the 2020 fpt threshold in the continental U.S. for one-person households is $12,760, with an additional $4,480 per household member. Thus, for a two-person household, the 150% fpt limit would be $25,860. In Hawaii and Alaska, the fpt thresholds differ (Hawaii +15%, Alaska +25%) as does the per family-member multiple (Alaska $5600, Hawaii $5150)
- For beneficiaries with a household income (MAGI) between 150 percent and 300 percent of federal poverty threshold ($25,860 - $51,720 for two-person households in the continental U.S.) set an annual COLA range of 1.5 percent minimum and 3 percent maximum.
- For beneficiaries with a household income (MAGI) exceeding 300 percent of federal poverty threshold ($51,720 for two-person households in the continental U.S.), set an annual COLA range of .5 percent minimum and 1.5 percent maximum.
Under the AMAC Social Security Guarantee plan, all retirees would be guaranteed an increase each year, although any Medicare premium increase could offset the value of a guaranteed COLA.
In any event, the 117th Congress will likely view the issue of Social Security reform with urgency, since several economic studies have advanced the expected date for full-depletion of the program’s trust fund reserves from 2035 to as early as later this decade.
This posting is presented for informational purposes only and does not represent legal or financial guidance. Any opinions or interpretations presented are either those of the original author or, in the case of articles authored by the AMAC Foundation, are the opinions of AMAC Foundation staff, originally trained and accredited by the National Social Security Association (NSSA) and certified via the AMAC Foundation. Any links included in the article are valid on the posted date; socialsecurityreport.org cannot guarantee the duration of the links’ validity. NSSA and the AMAC Foundation and its staff are not affiliated with or endorsed by the Social Security Administration or any other governmental entity. To submit a question, visit our website (https://amacfoundation.org/services/) or email us at ssadvisor@amacfoundation.org. Because we are a non-profit organization, there is no charge for these services.